Encomiums and … oh (bleep) it.

November 24, 2008 5:47 pm
by Brian White

This week’s Encomiums and Deprecations is being interrupted by this rant. (It’s about words, I promise.) This is only a rant. Your regularly scheduled enthusiastic praise and expressions of disapproval will resume next week.

Note: This post contains language. The regular kind and the profane kind.

I was watching a DVRed episode of Law and Order: Special Victims Unit last night when I was reminded of something that’s bothered me for a while. Some crime victim screamed and yelled and called another woman a bitch. Then I was watching a DVD of the X-Files today, and Agent John Doggett (Mulder’s replacement and apparently reformed T-1000) called a suspect a son of a bitch.

Why is it that on network television, where all sorts of profanity are not allowed, that bitch is? Why is it not OK for Bono to say, “This is really, really, fucking brilliant. Really, really, great,” or for the Philadelphia Phillies’ Chase Utley to say “World champions. World fucking champions!” on TV, but calling a woman a bitch is?

Think about it. Literally, fuck means “to have sex.” Bitch means “a female dog.” But Bono and Utley weren’t using fuck to mean “to have sex.” The Phillies aren’t the world champions of fucking. It doesn’t mean anything in that context. It really doesn’t. And it was on live TV. It wasn’t even scripted. Forget about hearing that in a recorded TV show.

But calling someone (or their mother) a bitch? That means something. You’re calling her a female dog. And it’s usually scripted. Someone thought about it.

So why is this OK? My guess: sexism. Don’t believe me? You ever hear a guy get called a faggot on network TV? Faggot isn’t even a traditional curse word. (Don’t get me wrong, it’s wrong to use it as a pejorative, it’s wrong to call someone that, and it is a foul, hurtful word.) But guys don’t get called that. Cocksucker? Nope. Asshole? Nope. Dickface? Nope. Any of the other dirty, dirty words some guys throw at each other on a regular basis? Nope. Or even the word shit in any context, defecatory or not? Nope.

But call a woman a bitch? No problem. I’ve seen it even on woman-friendly shows like the late, great Veronica Mars. You hear it everywhere on network TV. It’s the only one of the dirty words you do. Is there another explanation for why the networks and the FCC doesn’t care about it?

All that being said, I don’t have a problem with cursing on TV, be it network, cable, or HBO. It’s the way people talk, and I think the way cursing is treated in the United States gives it a power it really shouldn’t have. They’re words like any other. Not magic, evil words. Just words.

But if you are going to ban them, ban them across the board. Or allow them all. But don’t tell me that calling a woman a bitch in the nastiest, most vicious tone of voice is worse than dropping the f-bomb in an unscripted, live moment of joy.

7 Responses leave one →
  1. November 24, 2008 9:34 pm

    I’ll back you on your underlying thought, but I’m not sure a can go with how you got there.

    Calling a man a faggot isn’t analogous to calling a woman a bitch. Even calling someone a cocksucker doesn’t really mean the same thing as calling him a faggot.

    That having been said, on NYPD Blue, Andy call one of the D.A.’s a dickhead.

  2. November 24, 2008 9:35 pm

    Yes, there’s a typo. or two. and bad HTML.

  3. November 24, 2008 9:40 pm

    Well, it depends on the context of calling someone a faggot. If you’re saying it about someone who is gay to be hateful, it’s not the same. If it’s something said in anger or frustration or mockery of one’s manliness, “You’re such a fag,” or “Don’t be a fag,” or whatever, then I think it’s fairly close to calling a woman a bitch.

    As for NYPD Blue, I’ve never seen the show. Sounds like they bent the rules there. I approve.

  4. November 24, 2008 9:57 pm

    “The Phillies aren’t the world champions of fucking.”

    They’re not? Dammit. *Another* dream shattered. Sigh.

  5. November 25, 2008 3:27 pm
    April Korbel permalink

    The other problem is that their is no good male equivalent. Call someone a bastard and he’ll treat it like a compliment.
    I was watching original runs of Night Court (mid 80s) when someone decided you could say “bitch” once in a half hour.
    I also noticed recently when the word ass was uttered several times on All My Children. Daytime TV is usually very traditional, linguistically anyway.

  6. November 26, 2008 11:56 am
    Clare Bohn permalink

    April: Calling someone a bastard is, if you think about it, also an insult to his mother rather than directly to him.

    Brian: Language! But I agree with you, absolutely.

  7. November 28, 2008 8:31 am

    I suppose using ‘bitch’ would be permissible on a TV show about dogs; does that make its use somehow more acceptable in other (offensive) contexts?

    Probably not, because ‘faggot’ could be used on a show about meatballs.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Faggot_(food)

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS